THE JUDGE.William Falder,you have been given fair trial and found guilty,in my opinion rightly found guilty,of forgery.[He pauses;then,consulting his notes,goes on]The defence was set up that you were not responsible for your actions at the moment of committing this crime.There is no,doubt,I think,that this was a device to bring out at first hand the nature of the temptation to which you succumbed.For throughout the trial your counsel was in reality making an appeal for mercy.The setting up of this defence of course enabled him to put in some evidence that might weigh in that direction.Whether he was well advised to so is another matter.He claimed that you should be treated rather as a patient than as a criminal.And this plea of his,which in the end amounted to a passionate appeal,he based in effect on an indictment of the march of Justice,which he practically accused of confirming and completing the process of criminality.Now,in considering how far I should allow weight to his appeal;I have a number of factors to take into account.I have to consider on the one hand the grave nature of your offence,the deliberate way in which you subsequently altered the counterfoil,the danger you caused to an innocent man--and that,to my mind,is a very grave point--and finally I have to consider the necessity of deterring others from following your example.On the other hand,I have to bear in mind that you are young,that you have hitherto borne a good character,that you were,if I am to believe your evidence and that of your witnesses,in a state of some emotional excitement when you committed this crime.I have every wish,consistently with my duty--not only to you,but to the community--to treat you with leniency.And this brings me to what are the determining factors in my mind in my consideration of your case.You are a clerk in a lawyer's office--that is a very serious element in this case;there can be no possible excuse made for you on the ground that you were not fully conversant with the nature of the crime you were committing,and the penalties that attach to it.It is said,however,that you were carried away by your emotions.The story has been told here to-day of your relations with this--er--Mrs.
Honeywill;on that story both the defence and the plea for mercy were in effect based.Now what is that story?It is that you,a young man,and she,a young woman,unhappily married,had formed an attachment,which you both say--with what truth I am unable to gauge--had not yet resulted in immoral relations,but which you both admit was about to result in such relationship.Your counsel has made an attempt to palliate this,on the ground that the woman is in what he describes,I think,as "a hopeless position."As to that I can express no opinion.She is a married woman,and the fact is patent that you committed this crime with the view of furthering an immoral design.Now,however I might wish,I am not able to justify to my conscience a plea for mercy which has a basis inimical to morality.
It is vitiated 'ab initio',and would,if successful,free you for the completion of this immoral project.Your counsel has made an attempt to trace your offence back to what he seems to suggest is a defect in the marriage law;he has made an attempt also to show that to punish you with further imprisonment would be unjust.I do not follow him in these flights.The Law is what it is--a majestic edifice,sheltering all of us,each stone of which rests on another.
I am concerned only with its administration.The crime you have committed is a very serious one.I cannot feel it in accordance with my duty to Society to exercise the powers I have in your favour.You will go to penal servitude for three years.
FALDER,who throughout the JUDGE'S speech has looked at him steadily,lets his head fall forward on his breast.RUTH starts up from her seat as he is taken out by the warders.There is a bustle in court.
THE JUDGE.[Speaking to the reporters]Gentlemen of the Press,Ithink that the name of the female witness should not be reported.
The reporters bow their acquiescence.THE JUDGE.[To RUTH,who is staring in the direction in which FALDER has disappeared]Do you understand,your name will not be mentioned?
COKESON.[Pulling her sleeve]The judge is speaking to you.
RUTH turns,stares at the JUDGE,and turns away.
THE JUDGE.I shall sit rather late to-day.Call the next case.
CLERK of ASSIZE.[To a warder]Put up John Booley.
To cries of "Witnesses in the case of Booley":
The curtain falls.
